Similar to how my scrawling high school handwriting has devolved through decades of PC word processing, my natural urge to stop and save a game faded away. I attribute this to the emergence of automatic saving, checkpoints, console quick-resume features, and titles where the tension is so high that I can’t help but save obsessively in case things blow up. But I’m not perfect. Laziness creeps in. And this week, I was taught a crucial piece of wisdom after significant time invested in the newly ported Pokémon FireRed on Nintendo's console: one must always manually hit save.
It had been years since I last played a pixel-art Pokémon adventure — having missed the boat on the GBA era, 2000’s Pokémon Gold and Silver may have been the last mainline Poké-title I invested in. So I was pumped to pay the asking price for the nostalgic return back to Kanto, and a run to catch those classic 151 pocket monsters. I quickly returned to the glory days. During a handful of gaming sessions, I snagged Caterpie and Weedle, picked up an early Pikachu, beat Brock without trouble, took a chance on purchasing the Magikarp from a shady character, and journeyed through Mt. Moon completely unconcerned.
The fatal flaw: I never saved my game! And never thought to.
Alas, Jigglypuff can never be friends with that Mankey.
Everything went wrong during a session when I wasn't even playing… and as my daughter grabbed the Switch for a brief session of the newer Pokémon title in its place, shutting down my session to do so. As any Switch user understands (as I should have known…) opening a new game on Switch forces the closure of any software running. Your progress is only safe following an automatic save or if you remembered to save prior to changing games. Oops.
The Development of Save Systems: From Manual to Automatic
It's fair to consider automatic saving, now so seamless its operation is largely unconscious, as a true “cutting-edge” breakthrough. Although the classic text game Zork featured among the first save systems in gaming, the 1986 Zelda title is frequently recognized as a milestone moment for not feeling totally ruined after a game over because of cartridge-based saving on the classic console. Naturally, the onus was still on you to save. (And once you erred), the lesson was learned for life. Through the 1990s, memory cards on consoles including the original PlayStation made saving more common yet still fragile; forgetting to save (or having a card corrupt) could erase countless hours. Titles such as Resident Evil even turned saving into a limited resource.
Modern autosave, which suppressed my manual save habit my FireRed run so completely, gained prominence at the dawn of a new century. Halo: Combat Evolved introduced checkpoint saving as the Call of Duty series perfected the mechanic to ease frustration and eliminate repetition. As experiences became more vast — and focused on exploration — devs cracked the code for saving without interruption and, eventually, the ultimate convenience of instant on/off.
The Pokémon Series' Path: From Conscious Choice to Unconscious Backup
Curiously, this iconic franchise serves as a perfect mirror of how saving has changed. For decades, saving in a Pokémon game was a deliberate choice: players were trained to hit “Save” prior to shutting off their device. Starting with Pokémon Sword and Shield for the Nintendo Switch, the games added an autosave feature (which players could turn off), representing a substantial design shift within one of the industry's most most tradition-bound franchises.
I can admit failure: Years of playing Breath of the Wild and contemporary Nintendo titles utterly weakened my manual save reflex. I am still wary under specific circumstances — I refuse to chance quitting during a run in something like Hades 2 although I know full well it autosaves after chambers — but whether it’s been too long since I sank time older game design, or I'm simply pampered, the thought never entered my mind to manually save before redocking. My younger self would never have fumbled this badly.
The Result: Starting From Scratch
I have not returned to FireRed after my data loss incident. When I saw the title screen again to find just a lone Squirtle on my roster, my motivation evaporated. Status condition: Burned.
I might give it another shot… or I could just continue playing the ocean of contemporary releases dropping every day which gently presume I need my hand held. Nevertheless, my affection for classic games isn’t dead. On occasions when I can convince my child to take a break from her current favorite, we’ve been tag-teaming some retro multiplayer mayhem. Those classic titles skipped saving altogether relying purely on cryptic character strings. So, even if I make a fatal mistake, the setback is minimal. That, at least, is reassuring.